Canadian Electrical Wholesaler

Feb 4, 2019

PerspectiveBy Owen Hurst


We often learn how to look forward by first looking back, or at the very least we realize that despite our best efforts we have not truly advanced quite so much as we had thought. Sure, technology is rapidly advancing. That’s beyond question. But what about our approach to selling it? Have we changed that much in the last 20, 40, 60 years? Inevitably there have been advances and changes in marketing, the Internet causing the biggest shift, but many of the concerns and directives that have driven the distribution and marketing of industrial electrical products remain, or at least planted the roots of the concerns of manufacturers and distributors today.
To gain perspective of the perceptions and directions of electrical product distribution in 1960, we turn to Edwin H. Lewis. In 1960 Lewis published “The Distribution of Industrial Electrical Products” in the Journal of Marketing.


To fully define electrical product distribution in 1960, Lewis broke his study into several categories. We will follow his direction and provide his insights on the industry in each of the categories he identified.


The market


When considering the industrial market as a whole in 1960, Lewis identified that the primary users were electrical contractors, industrial, commercial and governmental organizations, and electric utilities. However, it is interesting to note that, while small, the DIY market was identified and making purchases in 1960, although it was but a blip in the overall purchasing of industrial electrical equipment.


Competition in the market occurred primarily in product design and performance, price, and technical services. Secondary to this and identified as only significant “under certain conditions” were sales promotion, product availability and delivery services. “In the sales of electrical apparatus, the reputation of the manufacturer as a producer of high quality, dependable products [is] a factor of overriding importance. Price becomes important when competing products are comparable in all essential respects.”[2]


Customer buying methods


Dependable products were the essential determining factor for buyers, and only after all operating factors had been considered. Lewis identifies that utilities tended to be conservative in their purchasing and that new suppliers had difficulty gaining acceptance unless they had a product required by the utility. Lewis noted that utilities that limited themselves to one or two suppliers for a given product ran a risk in terms of continuous availability and product limitations. Optimally utilities would have had a select number of suppliers for a given product.


Industrials also tended to purchase very carefully, as their primary concern was shutdown or disruption. Primary purchasing from industrials tends to follow along the line of manufacturer, as engineers and maintenance staff preferred to continue with a specific manufacturer if they have had past success with their products.

Construction materials


Electrical contractors, working primarily in the non-residential market, were often limited in their purchasing decisions by specifications written by the architects and engineers who designed the building. Therefore, Lewis identified that electrical contractors bidding on projects were restricted in their product purchasing, even though there may have been some flexibility within the identified specifications.


At this point we reach some confusing and contradictory opinions by Lewis on the best approach to swaying architects and engineers who are determining product specifications. First, he identifies that as architects and engineers have such an influence it is necessary for manufacturers to “devote considerable promotional effort to them in both personal selling and in advertising.”[3] He then goes on to say that “specifications are usually written around the descriptions of products which the engineer knows and trusts. Although the engineer is not likely to be influenced greatly by strong promotional pressure, he is influenced by good performance data.”[4]
In this regard 1960 doesn’t seem all that different than 2018. Yes, it is necessary to wisely target those specifying projects with advertising and promotional campaigns. However, their influence depends largely on the manufacturers’ reputation for providing reliable product.


Original equipment

Original equipment manufacturers (OEM) are purchasers of components to be used in finished products. In 1960 these were primarily identified as manufacturers of motors and motor controls, transformers, ballasts, wire and cable, and wiring devices (harnesses). OEM accounts tend to be large in scale and are often done as bulk orders. Lewis notes that some manufacturers sell the majority of their product to OEMs, which was not surprising in 1960 as electronics and electric household appliances were currently booming and demanding a substantial share of the electrical component market.

In other instances, motor manufacturers developed long-standing arrangements, particularly for companies building large motors. “Where supplier and purchaser have worked together for a long period, the working relations are close, and the supplier becomes almost a department of the OEM.”[5] This is quite an interesting observation by Lewis, and I would be interested to know if a supplier with a long-standing relationship with an OEM would today consider themselves in the manner identified in 1960 by Lewis.


Marketing structure


Lewis identified that in 1960 the market structure was primarily divided into two groupings:


    • sales of large apparatus, like those used in utility installations were primarily undertaken directly from the manufacturer, as they often required custom-made equipment. In this case manufacturers often act as the installers and assume some responsibility for the installation and performance of the product.


    • smaller equipment, wiring devices and supplies, lighting fixtures and such, which were sold primarily through distributors. Interesting that even in 1960 Lewis notes the term “distributor” is used rather than wholesaler.”[6] In all, the description of the electrical distributor in 1960 doesn’t sound all that different from today: they “sell primarily to electrical contractors and industrial accounts where the company handles its own installations.” They are both small and large companies, and although they have a general description they can be grouped into distributors general-line (what we would call full-line) and specialty-line that tend to specialize sales in a particular area that still meets the overall definition of sales to electrical contractors.

Lewis also notes that at the time there was a rising rend in distributors operating electrical contractor businesses, although this tended to affect the distributor sales as they tended to not want to sell to competitors of their contracting business. So, has opinion really changed that much in 58 years?


Other wholesalers


Today it is no surprise to hear concerns, particularly for smaller companies, about the rise of big box hardware stores that supply electrical supplies at an often discounted rate. But that discussion is not a new one and was identified as a rising concern by Lewis in 1960. Although it may not have been stores such as Home Depot, or even the rising tide of online sales (although I would love to go back to 1960 and see the puzzled face of distributors when using that lingo) distributors were still facing competition from hardware locations. There was also a trend for electrical service establishments to take on the role of a wholesaler, although the trend was rather short lived.

The manufacturers’ representative

Lewis admits that in addition to merchant (hardware) wholesalers there is a key middleman in the distribution of electrical products, namely the manufacturer’s rep. Lewis notes that in 1960 they existed if a manufacturer could not maintain an adequate salesforce, and that reps often represented multiple manufacturers with similar products. I think we can say this is rather unique and that manufacturers that are in competition do not share reps.

Changes in distribution


This section may be the most interesting of Lewis’ article as it looks at the period from 1950 to 1960 and the changes in distribution that occurred in that 10-year period. From 1950 to 1960 Lewis identified that the “general-line, full-service distributor particularly has been under pressure. This pressure has been caused by the increasing severity of price competition, especially on bid business, and the need on the part of both manufacturers and distributors to reduce costs. In addition, manufacturers have not always been satisfied with the job distributors have done and have begun to assume a greater responsibility for some functions formerly performed by the distributor such as warehousing and sales promotion.”[7]


Another change during the period was the rise of manufacturers’ own field stocks, particularly by wire and cable manufacturers. He notes that distributors looked unfavourably at these field stocks, considering them to have the potential to directly compete for market share.


Interestingly Lewis also identifies that in major cities there had arisen a new market for mail-order parts, which he notes may or may not be of premium quality, but prices tended to be low and attractive to contractors. This is eerily reminiscent of online product purchases, which also come with the prospect of low prices and can be of low quality or at times even carry counterfeit certification marks.

And finally, promotional activities rose substantially from 1950 to 1960 among both manufacturers and agents. This at times took the role of training salesmen and direct relationships with users.

“The net effect of these developments has been that the established position of the electrical distributor is challenged by contractors who attempt to buy direct and by agents and manufacturers who ‘go around’ the distributor, take orders from contractors, and then attempt to place the order with some distributor at the lowest possible price.”[8]

Owen Hurst is Managing Editor of Panel Builder & Systems Integrator. Source: Edwin H. Lewis. “The Distribution of Industrial Electrical Equipment,” Journal of Marketing 24 (4) (1960), pp. 23-28

Notes
    1. Edwin H. Lewis. “The Distribution of Industrial Electrical Equipment,” Journal of Marketing 24 (4) (1960), pp. 23-28
    2. Lewis, p. 23
    3. Lewis, p. 24
    4. Ibid
    5. Ibid
    6. Lewis, p. 25
    7. Lewis, p. 26
    8. Lewis, p. 27

Latest Articles

  • Prev
Britech Corp, one of Canada’s largest heating cable companies has signed a formal agreement with ...
Leaders and innovators from business, government and the education sector gathered for this ABB ...
Hitachi has a deal with industrial giant ABB to purchase 80% of their Power Grids division for ...
I can still remember August 5, 2014 like it was yesterday. This date marks my first day as a ...
In setting growth plans for the coming year, one should ask, “What percentage of my customers might ...
The stigma behind dealing with contractors has forever been “they are a tough group to build a ...
Perhaps the better question is, “Why does it matter what young marketers want?” The answer is that ...
The Channel Marketing Group / William Blair Q3 2018 Pulse of Lighting Report shows that the ...
Following months-long renovations, Deschenes officially opened a renovated service counter at its ...
A question I sometimes ask managers and salespeople when I speak at conferences is, “How much ...

 

Westburne WOWLed by Divisional Lighting Manager Salma Siddiqui, the initiative will focus on making Westburne the workplace of choice in the electrical industry and beyond.

Results from research conducted by Westburne found that the electrical industry has a ratio of 3:1 of male vs. female employees. “Realizing these stats are the industry norm has made our eyes open and realize we need to make a change and showcase our women who work for us and at the same time make Westburne the place women would love to work for,” the company says.



Read More

 

 

 

Westburne and RockwellThe Authorized Service Provider designation enables Westburne to deliver Rockwell Automation services through their factory trained team of specialists. These services include installed base evaluation, network assessment, arc flash assessment, lockout/tag-out assessment, and start-up of variable frequency drives.

According to Steve Roy, Regional Sales Manager for Rockwell Automation Canada, “Customer expectations continue to evolve. Aging infrastructure, workforce gaps, global competition and an explosion of new technology provide endless opportunities for customers to improve their businesses.

Read More

 

IdeaIDEA plans to introduce an online learning management tool, the IDEA Learning Portal, to train customers on the new IDEA Connector, which will launch in late September. This portal will contain comprehensive training information and documentation on the IDEA Connector, a master data management (MDM) platform that enables distributors to securely access accurate and timely product and pricing data directly from manufacturers.

To complement the portal, there will be four training session devoted to manufacturers and distributors at eBiz. These training sessions will dive deeper into specific content to ensure a complete understanding of important functionality.

Read More

LFI Innovation AwardsThe celebrated LFI Innovation Awards marked the opening this week of the 2019 Lightfair International Trade Show and Conference with a dramatic showcasing of the industry’s most innovative products and designs introduced during the last 12 months.

The 2019 awards and trade show opening mark the 30th anniversary of the world’s largest annual lighting and technology event. The 2019 awards saw entries spanning 14 categories, with each submission judged by an independent panel of lighting professionals. Winning entries exemplified the best in innovative design and thinking. 

Read More

 

Automation LabourforceBy: Thomas Donato, Rockwell Automation

We all are consumers. We all have expectations of quality and service.

When I talk to our customers, I do so with that experience and mindset. If we don’t deliver – we lose. Maybe not immediately, but eventually. It’s as simple as that.

I just lived through a great example of this. Every morning I use our blender. One of the parts broke, and the manufacturer made it quite difficult and cumbersome to get a replacement.

Read More

Changing Scene

  • Prev
At Electro-Federation Canada’s recent Annual General Meeting in Quebec City, the Nominating ...
Pilz Canada officially opened their Canadian Facility surrounded by Industry Partners, colleagues ...
Dr. Jayson Meyers, CEO of NGen — Next Generation Manufacturing Canada — will present on the topic ...
Last week, over 540 industry members and guests gathered at the EFC Conference in Quebec City, ...
Cree, Inc. has completed the sale of its Lighting Products business unit, Cree Lighting, to Ideal ...
Kelly Hanson has joined Ryan and Chris Maguire as agency Principal. Kelly has an extensive sales ...
AD, the contractor and industrial products wholesale buying/marketing group, reported a 7% increase ...
Legrand has promoted Scott Bausch to Vice President/General Manager for the Wiremold product ...
  The OmniCable Toronto branch recently completed its first customer order after opening ...
The Hannover Messe Trade Fair in Germany, held this year at the beginning of April, is the world’s ...

Eric TeacherLiteline Corporation is pleased to announce the promotion of Eric Teacher to National Specification Manager for Canada.

Eric Joined Liteline in February as Regional Manager - Specifications for Ontario, Canada and quickly became an indispensable resource to the Sales, Marketing and Product Development teams. Eric has extensive experience in the Lighting and Controls industry.

 

 

Read More

 

 

Customer Service Leadership SummitAt the one day Customer Service Leadership Summit, pick up expert insights, advice and tips on how to grow your business, engage team members, and make price less relevant.

Here are four reasons you and your leadership team should attend.

1. Make price less relevant


You already know that in today’s commoditized marketplace, your #1 competitive advantage is your team’s service. And it’s one of the few things you have total control over.

Read More

 

ABB Showcases Its Vision of Leadership in Digital Industries at ABB Customer World 2019

Show ReportBy Line Goyette

Leaders and innovators from business, government and the education sector gathered for this ABB premier collaboration event. More than 11,000 delegates attended the bi-annual ABB Customer World Houston 2019 from March 4 to 7 in Houston, Texas. ABB’s latest pioneering technologies were displayed over 150,000 sq ft of a colourful, buzzy display of futuristic conveyor belts and robots, an ABB Formula E Generation 2 car, and much more groundbreaking technology.

Read More

 

 

Looking Back

  • Prev
The best memory I keep from CEDA is the way that they accepted me when I came into the business. ...
In the 1930s to 1940s, CEDA’s Western Canada membership was very stable with old line independent ...
Prior to the late 1950s there was little if any involvement in CEDA by the so-called “national ...
  As 2017 marks the 150th anniversary of Confederation, we take a look back at an aspect of ...

Copper $US Dollar price per pound

Kerrwil Publications

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2019 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil