Canadian Electrical Wholesaler



November 14, 2016 

By David Gordon and Victoria Gustafson

With 2016 coming to a close, planning for 2017 is here. Manufacturers and distributors are finalizing their sales and marketing plans, setting sales and operational goals, and hopefully jointly discussing ways to increase sales and make both parties more profitable.

During this time, top-down and/or bottom-up forecasts will be reconciled, and new goals will be passed down. Since the economy is forecasted to grow at low single-digit rates, manufacturers and distributors are forced to find new sources of growth to deliver growth and gain market share. A targeted, effective joint business planning (JPB) process between key partners is the instrument that can deliver just that.

The planning cycle in most companies consists of:

1.   creating the base plan

2.   adjusting it for market conditions

3.   using joint business planning to find incremental opportunities (see Figure 1)

Figure 1

Base plans take into account sales in the previous year, major business changes, such as mergers, acquisitions and divestitures, and corporate goals, such as compensating for increase in the cost of goods sold. For the purposes of illustration, let’s assume the base plan should, based on 2016 performance, contribute 97% of 2017 plans. These plans are then adjusted to incorporate market conditions.

Although specific indicators taken into account vary by industry, most often they are things like inflation, GDP, construction / industrial production forecasts, industry-specific metrics and changes in industry, or company distribution (gain or loss major accounts, entering new territories, etc). Under current economic conditions this adjustment will result in 3% growth. Combinations of these plans will add up to 100% of the “realistic” 2017 plan — a solid plan that ensures the company grows at the same pace with the market.

But it will not deliver incremental growth or market share increases.

To ensure real growth, companies must look to incremental opportunities that are below the surface. These usually consist of regional, account-specific, end-user driven opportunities that require careful planning and execution. Based on research in other industries, in particular consumer packaged goods (CPG), partners who participate and execute a joint business planning process on average grow at almost 4% faster than those who do not. This means that in a lukewarm market companies can double their growth rate by exercising and executing a JBP.

Due to its importance in driving growth, Channel Marketing Group, in partnership with Verde Associates, conducted extensive research that pursued a three-fold goal:

1. understand how a joint business process works today for many manufacturers and distributors

2. assess satisfaction with the current process

3. uncover improvement opportunities that can be implemented for the 2017 planning cycle

The research included a survey of manufacturers and electrical distributors, in-depth interviews with key decision-makers and a deep dive into the important topic of rebates, which is also a driver of joint business planning.

Our research showed that although most companies do go through joint business planning with their major partners, the process is not optimal for most companies and many plans are open to a major overhaul. While there are specific elements that may need to change, a key element is changing the expectation level to be more optimistic about the potential outcome.

Of the six steps of the current process, three function relatively well, and three need major improvement (see Figure 2).

Figure 2

In fact, half of distributors and the majority of manufacturers are not fully satisfied with today’s JBP process. The good news is that there is wide acknowledgement that the process is needed and that it works pretty well with some partners.

The reasons for dissatisfaction are uniform between manufacturers and distributors. They have to do with the focus, quality and dedication to the process. If it’s not well thought through and executed, it becomes just another exercise to go through, but participants don’t get any value from it. So, there is a big opportunity to revamp the process to make it of value and help drive growth and improved profits.

Based on our research, major areas for improvements include:

1. Topics covered by JBP

·     focus on value-add issues

·     broaden customer needs discussions

·     extend time horizon

2. Quality and granularity of market research used to generate insights

·     regional and trading area-level insights

·     end-customer research

3. Value received from the process

·     meaningful and actionable outcomes

·     minimize efforts/maximize results

4. JPB effectiveness

·     implementation in the field

·     periodic measurement and accountability

What we found is that manufacturers and distributors are looking for more relevant and meaningful topics that truly uncover joint opportunities. This is directly connected to the quality of research that goes into finding these opportunities, especially local market and end-customer research. Increasing the value of the process is of high importance, again, because of its resource intensity, but, more importantly, a lost opportunity to find growth where there is very little of it occurring naturally. And, finally, the effectiveness of the process that comes from measurement, accountability, and holding all parties responsible for results.

In a nutshell, the process does exist and is exercised but it has a ways to go to produce the results that companies want and expect from it.

When asked about top value topics that drive the JBP process, manufacturers and distributors agreed that sales, market share and strategic alignment were the key contributors.

The third area of value centred on customers, specifically customer training, events and account-specific strategies – in essence, all customer engagement and relationship-oriented tactical elements. The focus is clearly tactical. There is an opportunity to extend the discussion to include strategic, long-term objectives, such as customer loyalty, customer acquisition and revenue retention.

Figure 3

Our research showed that rebates have a very special place in the JBP process. In particular, over 50% of distributors feel that planning improves their potential of achieving goals tied to rebates. We discovered that rebate achievement is a “hope” strategy for many rather than a carefully planned and executed plan. We also saw that, in some instances, a rebate is table stakes for manufacturers to engage distribution.

Market research is an underutilized strategic and joint business planning tool. Few use it to uncover opportunities to achieve incremental growth. Resources do exist to facilitate this, however, typically manufacturer sales personnel are not exposed, educated, or trained on the tools or information.

There is also a marketing research dichotomy. Manufacturers think they do a better job leveraging research during the planning process with distributors than distributors feel they do. While distributors were either Dissatisfied or Very Dissatisfied with the market research that manufacturers put into JPB presentations, almost half of distributors feel the research is only adequate. So the issue becomes - how do you amplify knowledge without amplifying costs? The key is to determine what information is needed to address the issue and drive the business and then seek appropriate information. Every industry / market has information available. Sometimes it helps to have a third party to help decipher and find it.

Much opportunity lies in measurement and accountability, as both are integral to a successful JBP. None of the survey participants said that any of their implementations were Extremely Effective. The overall feeling is that while in-field implementation (sales planning) does take place, it could use improvements to really deliver on agreed upon goals (see Figure 4)

Figure 4

On the positive side, it works if the plan is executed correctly and measured consistently and if follow through and periodic reviews takes place.

Our research showed that there is inconsistency in JBP development and execution within a company and nationally. JBP is highly dependent on distributor and manufacturer engagement and can be directly proportional to the level of management involved as well as pre-meeting information sharing. Respondents also pointed out that implementation needs follow-through and accountability, coupled with razor-sharp focus to achieve desired results.

The takeaway from the research is that individual companies that seek above average growth need to change their JBP planning process to capture sales and market share. The question becomes “Are companies committed to making a change or is it lip service?”

 When asked about their willingness to change their joint business planning process for the 2017 planning cycle, the majority of manufacturers and half of distributors said yes. In particular, the following improvement opportunities were identified:

·     more transparency

·     pro-activity

·     more granular information sharing

·     making the process more valuable and selective, implementing a clear set of metrics with rigid periodic reviews

·     require higher efficiency through better preparation and better tools, build in tracking and accountability, and focus on most valuable opportunities

To summarize, here are some recommendations to improve your joint business planning effectiveness:

·     Commit to extract value from planning and to remember that it’s a revenue driver, not an obligation. Without accountability there will be no delivered value and that others will not respect what is not expected… and compensated or recognized. Hope is not a viable strategy.

·     Come to meetings prepared and expect the same of your planning partner.

·     Determine if the meeting objective is revenue generation or profit improvement (or what % each). Research shows that manufacturers always want to focus on sales, whereas distributors are primarily focused on profitability and secondarily on sales growth.

·     Excellent ability to develop and deliver on JBP plans can be a differentiator and reputation builder for both manufacturers and distributors. People, and companies, want to work with those who are committed to helping them grow… and can do it by executing upon a plan.

·     Engage at appropriate levels and drive communications downstream.

·     Remember: data identify, quantify and prioritize opportunities. Discussion determines if there is a desire to pursue them.

·     Consider selective and customized planning approach. Not all “partners” are created equal.

·     Planning must be important to management and be management-driven, otherwise it is usually poorly executed and a waste of time.

The key to JBP? Develop the plan, implement the plan, measure achievement to identify areas ongoing improvement and you’ll get the planned results.

David Gordon is President of Channel Marketing Group, a strategic planning, marketing planning and market research firm focused on supporting manufacturers and distributors in the construction and industrial trades. He can be reached at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or 919-488-8635. Victoria Gustafson is a partner at Verde Associates. Verde works with companies to accelerate growth through data-driven decision-making and process improvement. The two collaborate on clients to bring multiple perspectives and skill sets to bear on client challenges.



Economy EmploymentAs a result of widespread measures taken to contain the spread of COVID-19, the Canadian economy contracted 11.6% in April, following a 7.5% drop in March. By the end of May, many businesses had begun to adapt to the new reality by shifting to teleworking, reducing hours, laying off staff, applying for government funding or seeking rent relief.

As pandemic-related restrictions were gradually lifted throughout the summer, the business climate began to improve slightly. For example, real gross domestic product grew 1.2% in August, the fourth consecutive monthly increase, which continued to offset the steepest drops in Canadian economic activity on record that were observed in March and April. 

Read More


Swati Vora-PatelBy Swati Vora-Patel

“As a distributor, we need to build capabilities around experiences, data and the technologies that are driving change… It’s important that we listen, experiment and help lead our customers forward.” Chief Marketing Officer, Distributor — from the book Innovate to Dominate: The 12th Edition in the Facing the Forces of Change Series

Mapping your company’s digital transformation begins with an outside-in approach. 

Read More


COVID AirBy Angela Jamieson and Marc Laplante

The importance of clean air has been thrust into the spotlight with the emergence of COVID-19 and the rapidly spreading infections related to it. Examples have emerged around the world showing how aerosols may be playing a role in transmission; the choir practise in Washington State where over 80% of their members were infected (primary or secondary)1 after their final practice before shutting down for COVID restrictions, or the restaurant in Guangzhou, China where COVID-19 was theorized to have spread according to the air movement from an air conditioning system2. 

Read More



Carol McGloganBy Carol McGlogan

When it comes to marketing and customers, some things never change, while some things are always evolving! The parts that never change for marketers are that we need to be where our customers are, when they need us, and with the right information. The parts that are in constant flux are our customers’ buying behaviours and the technologies available to intervene and influence the customer experience.

COVID-19 has forced us all into new habits both personally and in business. For instance, social isolation has caused us to rely more heavily on technology to fill in the gaps. 

Read More


Changing Scene

  • Prev
Schneider Electric announced today the promotion of Adrian Thomas to country ...
The Zigbee Alliance, an organization of hundreds of companies creating, maintaining, and ...
ETIM North America (NA) is pleased to announce that the National Electrical Manufacturers ...
Strong rebound in Q3 2020;Revenue up +1.3% organic - Full Year 2020 targets upgraded...   ...
Power management company Eaton Corporation plc announced that earnings per share were $1.11 for the ...
 We may not be able to celebrate in person this year, but EFC would like to invite you to ...
Since 1945 the Stamm family has proudly owned Powrmatic of Canada. Despite this 75 yearlong history ...
The Stelpro Group, owner of Stelpro, the NorthThe Stelpro Group, owner of Stelpro, the ...
IMARK Canada is pleased to announce that Concord Electric Supply, Concord, ON is a member of IMARK ...
E.B. Horsman & Son is excited to announce EMPOWER, their Employee Share Ownership Plan ...


Zigbee AllianceThe Zigbee Alliance, an organization of hundreds of companies creating, maintaining, and delivering open, global standards for the Internet of Things (IoT), announced an important movement within the Project Connected Home over IP initiative, forming a team dedicated to the development and promotion of the standard for commercial markets.

This move is in alignment with the overall vision for the initiative, which is to develop and promote the adoption of a new, royalty-free connectivity standard, simplifying development for manufacturers and increasing compatibility for customers and consumers.

Read More


EatonPower management company Eaton Corporation plc announced that earnings per share were $1.11 for the third quarter of 2020. Excluding charges of $0.05 per share related to acquisitions and divestitures and $0.02 per share related to a multi-year restructuring program, adjusted earnings per share were $1.18.

Sales in the third quarter of 2020 were $4.5 billion. Organic sales were down 9 percent, and the divestitures of the Lighting and Automotive Fluid Conveyance businesses reduced sales by 8 percent, partially offset by 2 percent growth from acquisitions.



Read More


CEW Stelpro flextherm 400The Stelpro Group, owner of Stelpro, is pleased to announce that it has acquired Flextherm, the electric floor heating industry. Flextherm was founded in 1991 by Philippe Charron, who brought a new vision to the market. Sustained work with the standard-setting bodies made it possible to revolutionize the industry by certifying heating cable installations directly on plywood, making the technology accessible to a greater number of people.

Many other innovations, including a complete range of heating cable products and controls and focus on quality and service helped build a strong brand over the years and raised the company to the enviable status it has today. 

Read More


Adrian Thomas and Annette ClaytonSchneider Electric announced today the promotion of Adrian Thomas to country president, Canada, effective January 1, 2021. Mr. Thomas succeeds Susan Uthayakumar, who held the role of country president for the past three years. Mr. Thomas will report to North American CEO & President, Annette Clayton.

Susan Uthayakumar, has been appointed as the global leader for Schneider Electric's Sustainability Business Division, reporting to Chief Strategy & Sustainability Officer, Olivier Blum. 


Read More


EFC 2020 Industry Awards

EFC 2020 Industry AwardsWe may not be able to celebrate in person this year, but EFC would like to invite you to their premier Industry Awards in a new and exciting virtual format. 

This year’s Electro-Federation Canada's 2020 Industry Awards will recognize member recipients through a virtual presentation honouring their strong leadership and commitment to contributing to the health of the industry. EFC's National Advisory Council chairman, Steve Branscombe, Independent Electric Supply, will emcee the Awards on Thursday, December 10th, 2020 at 4:30 pm EST.


Read More



Peers & Profiles

  • Prev
Headquartered in Concord, Ontario, Mercury Lighting services national retail, ...
“Never forget to look at the big picture.” These words of advice are from the father of Jason ...
Electrimat is an independent Quebec-owned company that has specialized for 40 years in the ...
In July, Eaton announced that Vice President, Channel – Electrical Sector, Matt Cleary would be ...
Tim King, Southwire Canada’s new President and first Canadian to assume the role, has taken the ...
Bogdan Botoi is Division Manager for Automation and Control with E.B. Horsman out of British ...
Mission Technical Solutions is a recently established sales agency founded by industry veteran ...

MercuryBy Blake Marchand

Headquartered in Concord, Ontario, Mercury Lighting services national retail, multi-residential/commercial property management, energy service companies (ESCO), and auto dealerships.

“From design to specifications, we offer turn-key services that go beyond the typical distributor model,” explained Mercury Lighting Vice President, Eric Tordjman. Their value-added approach leverages well-established supplier relations to help clients find a lighting solution that suits their needs.



Read More


Jason PrevostBy Line Goyette

“Never forget to look at the big picture.” These words of advice are from the father of Jason Prevost, his first mentor, who worked as a marketing specialist. Jason has repeated them often over the past two years during what might have been the hardest personal crisis of his life.

At a time when he was forced to reassess his professional future, his wife and the mother of his two teenage children was diagnosed with a virulent cancer.


Read More


Copper $US Dollar price per pound

Kerrwil Publications Great Place to Work. Certified December 2019 - December 2020

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2020 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil